Skip to content
Two Icons. Strategy, growth, people.
Back to Insights

Commercial Growth & Reinvention

We’re spending on marketing. What’s actually helping us win business?

Joe Papadatos

Before you spend more or change providers, look at what created your recent enquiries, what helped customers decide and what happened after your team took over.

If you lead an established Australian B2B business, you may be putting considerable time and money into marketing while winning much of your work through relationships, referrals and proposals. The team can show you the activity. Enquiries are coming through. But when you consider the next few months, you’re still unsure where to put your money.

Should you keep going, increase the budget, change the agency or bring someone in to take more responsibility? You want to give good work a fair chance, but you also need to recognise when something needs to change.

I built and led Icon Visual Marketing, growing it to a team of more than forty people before selling the business in 2023. My responsibilities included the work delivered for clients and the people, sales, pricing and performance of my own company. That experience shapes how I look at marketing: its contribution needs to be understood alongside what the rest of the business does with the opportunity.

“Referral” tells you where it started

A job recorded as a referral may also have involved a useful page on your website, a technical conversation and a prompt answer that gave the buyer confidence to proceed.

The introduction got you considered. Understanding what happened afterwards tells you more about what helped you win.

That matters when you are deciding what to back. A project example that helps a buyer understand your experience may be doing useful commercial work even if it rarely produces a direct enquiry.

The same care belongs on an opportunity that goes quiet. Your team may have missed an answer the buyer needed, or the buyer may have put the project on hold. The label in the CRM will not necessarily tell you which.

When the explanation is “we lost on price”

Price can absolutely be the reason. Your offer may have been too expensive for the work, or the customer may simply have had less to spend. There is no benefit in constructing a more flattering explanation when that is what happened.

But “too expensive” can also leave you with a very incomplete understanding of the decision.

A customer comparing two proposals may see a difference in price without understanding the difference in scope. Something you regard as essential might look optional to them. Your proposal may allow for work or support that the other proposal leaves out, without explaining why it matters. Or your team may have understood the brief differently from the beginning.

There is also the question of what the customer valued. It is easy to spend time explaining the strengths you are proud of while giving too little attention to the concern they are trying to resolve. A buyer worried about disruption to their operations may be looking for confidence in the delivery plan. More detail about your credentials may not answer that concern.

The person who handled the opportunity will have a useful view of this. Where possible, also hear from the customer. What did they understand about your offer? What made the other option more suitable? What remained uncertain when they made the decision?

You may still conclude that the price needs attention. But you might find that you need to explain the offer more clearly, qualify the opportunity earlier or change how you approach the sales conversation.

That distinction matters before you lower the price, increase the marketing budget or send the team out to pursue more of the same work.

Seven questions to understand what helped—or stopped—the sale

Choose a handful of recent wins and a handful of opportunities that were lost or have stalled, up to ten in each group where the records exist.

Keep the dates, value and status visible. Separate new customers from repeat work, and allow for the normal length of your buying cycle. An opportunity that takes six months to decide is not necessarily stalled because it has been quiet for a fortnight.

Bring together the people who handled the work and answer the seven questions below. Emails, proposals, CRM notes and customer feedback will help. Where nobody knows, leave the question open.

Two hypothetical examples: one piece of work won and one enquiry stalled. Neither is a Two Icons client case.

A referral that became a customer

1. What was the buyer trying to solve?

A manufacturer needed a maintenance partner who could work around production.

2. How did contact begin?

An existing customer made the introduction.

3. What did the buyer actually see or hear?

The buyer mentioned a project example on the website and a technical call. They did not say what other marketing they had seen.

4. What proof or reassurance did they ask for?

An example of similar work and a proposed schedule showing how disruption would be managed.

5. Who owned the next action?

The account manager took responsibility and sent the project example and schedule when promised.

6. What happened?

The customer accepted the proposal.

7. How sure are you about what mattered?

The customer said the relevant experience and clear delivery plan helped them choose. There may have been other influences they did not mention.

An enquiry that went quiet

1. What was the buyer trying to solve?

A manufacturer needed maintenance completed during a limited shutdown window.

2. How did contact begin?

A campaign enquiry came through the website.

3. What did the buyer actually see or hear?

The campaign and enquiry are recorded. The buyer has not said what else they looked at.

4. What proof or reassurance did they ask for?

Confirmation of crew availability for the shutdown dates.

5. Who owned the next action?

The sales manager needed to reply. The request went to operations without an agreed response date, and the answer was never sent.

6. What happened?

The opportunity remained open, with no further response. It had not been confirmed as lost.

7. How sure are you about what mattered?

Emails show the missed answer. Nobody has spoken to the buyer since, so the reason for the silence is still unknown.

The first example gives you something to back: relevant proof, a useful technical conversation and a clear response. Making those easier for your team to use is a practical decision supported by the customer’s account.

The second gives you something to fix. Find out whether the project is still active, provide an accurate answer and make someone responsible for getting it to the buyer. That action is justified even though the reason for the silence remains unknown.

For your own opportunities, record the person’s name against the next action. A department name can leave everyone assuming somebody else is dealing with it.

What does that tell you to do next?

The review should help you choose where to put your attention and money. It may reveal work worth continuing, something that needs changing or a question you cannot yet answer.

What the evidence suggests you should keep, change, stop or investigate.

What the review shows

Suitable customers arrive, progress and become worthwhile work

What to do next

Keep what is contributing. Check costs, margin and delivery capacity before testing an increase in spend.

What the review shows

Suitable enquiries go quiet while waiting for answers or proposals

What to do next

Change what happens after the enquiry. Examine response times, the offer, sales capability and the handover between teams.

What the review shows

Enquiries repeatedly come from customers you cannot serve well or profitably

What to do next

Change the targeting, message or brief. Stop or reduce activity that keeps attracting unsuitable work and has no useful role in its current form.

What the review shows

The agency repeatedly misses an agreed brief or its commitments

What to do next

Address supplier performance. Agree the correction required or change the arrangement.

What the review shows

Nobody can say who briefs the agency, follows up or reports back

What to do next

Change who carries those responsibilities. Start with the people you have; consider additional leadership where a gap remains.

What the review shows

Records are thin, explanations conflict or the buying cycle is unfinished

What to do next

Investigate the unanswered question. Name the information needed and who will obtain it.

These patterns help you choose what to examine; they don’t establish the cause by themselves. Check the agreed brief, the inputs your business supplied and the wider sales figures before attributing a result to one activity or supplier. A selected handful of opportunities can reveal a pattern; use the full pipeline to calculate win rates or compare channels.

One lost proposal does not establish that the pricing is wrong. A quiet month tells you little about a campaign intended to influence a decision that takes six months.

The review should still leave you with a decision you can name: keep, change, stop or investigate.

For example, “Change how requests for delivery timing are handled” is specific enough to assign. The sales manager could own the reply, operations could agree when it will provide the information, and the next review could examine whether promised answers reached customers on time. Whether those opportunities progress is a separate result to watch.

If the decision is to keep the current spend, write down what result would justify continuing and when you expect to see it. That gives “let’s give it more time” a purpose.

Someone has to see it through

An agency can adjust a campaign. A salesperson can improve a proposal. A delivery manager can explain what the business can realistically commit to. But a change that involves all three needs someone to make sure the conversations happen and the decisions are followed through.

For the owner, there is a familiar risk here. You recognise the problem, bring everyone together and get things moving. Then the next enquiry arrives and you find yourself doing it all again.

Part of the work is deciding what your team can carry, what authority they need and how you will stay informed. Otherwise, the improvement lasts only as long as you keep pushing it.

You may be able to resolve the issue with the people and providers already in place. The review should give you a firmer basis for deciding what support is missing before choosing someone new.

Turning effort into revenue

When you are responsible for the business, uncertainty about marketing can become expensive. You can continue spending because nobody can explain what to change, or stop useful work because its contribution has never been made clear.

A closer look at how customers are buying gives you a firmer basis for that decision. It helps you recognise the work worth backing and the changes that need your attention.

Through Two Icons, I work alongside leaders and their teams to understand those questions and put the agreed changes into practice. If the review leaves you with a pattern you need help working through, I’d be happy to talk.

Start a conversation with Joe.

Good thinking starts a conversation.

If this connects with what's happening in your business, let's talk.